Maui is a paradise for seafood lovers like me. The Pacific Ocean surrounds this beautiful Hawaiian island, so it’s no surprise that some of the freshest fish and shellfish can be found here. I’ve spent time exploring the local seafood scene and want to share my findings with you.
The best seafood restaurants on Maui range from high-end dining establishments to casual food trucks, all serving incredibly fresh catches straight from local waters. Whether you’re looking for traditional Hawaiian preparations or innovative fusion dishes, you’ll find amazing seafood options across the island. I can’t wait to tell you about my favorite spots!
Mama’s Fish House
Walking into Mama’s Fish House feels like entering a Polynesian paradise. The beautiful ocean views create a perfect backdrop for what’s about to be an unforgettable meal. I was immediately struck by the warm, tropical atmosphere that makes this place a true Maui landmark.
The seafood here is exceptionally fresh – they even name the fisherman who caught your fish on the menu! I tried their signature dish with fish caught that very morning, and the flavors were absolutely incredible. The preparation was simple yet elegant, allowing the natural quality of the ingredients to shine.
Be warned – you’ll need to plan well ahead for this dining experience. When I called to make my reservation, they mentioned they book up months in advance. The popularity is absolutely justified though, as every aspect of my meal was worth the wait.
I found the service to be just as impressive as the food. The staff shared fascinating stories about local fishing traditions and helped pair my seafood with the perfect tropical cocktail. It’s easy to see why this place has become a must-visit destination for seafood lovers on Maui.
Rating: 4.7 (9645 reviews)
Location: 799 Poho Pl, Paia, HI 96779
Contact: (808) 579-8488
Website: Visit Website
Honu Oceanside
I recently visited Honu Oceanside in Lahaina and was blown away by the experience. This modern oceanfront restaurant offers amazing views while you dine, making it a perfect spot to enjoy seafood on Maui. The restaurant has a lovely industrial-style decor that creates a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere.
The menu features delicious New England-style seafood dishes and brick-oven pizzas. I tried their fresh catch of the day which was perfectly prepared and bursting with flavor. Their cocktail selection is impressive too, with creative drinks that complement the food perfectly.
What makes Honu truly special is its location right on Front Street, steps from the ocean. I loved watching the waves while enjoying my meal. The service was attentive and friendly, with staff who were knowledgeable about both the menu and wine selections.
I’d recommend making reservations, especially during sunset hours when the views are most spectacular. This is definitely one of the best fine dining seafood experiences you’ll find on Maui, blending excellent food with that perfect oceanside setting.
Rating: 4.6 (1283 reviews)
Location: 1295 Front St, Lahaina, HI 96761
Contact: (808) 667-9390
Website: Visit Website
The Fish Market Maui
I recently visited The Fish Market Maui in Lahaina and was blown away by the fresh seafood options. This place is a perfect blend of market and restaurant, offering both local catches to take home and delicious prepared dishes to enjoy on the spot.
The menu features the day’s freshest catches, and I loved watching the staff prepare my fish right before my eyes. Their fish tacos were incredible – packed with perfectly seasoned fish and topped with a zesty sauce that complemented the flavor perfectly.
What makes this spot special is how they source directly from local fishermen. You can taste the difference in quality. The casual atmosphere adds to its charm, making it a great stop for a quick lunch during a day of exploring the west side of Maui.
I recommend trying their poke bowls if you visit. The fish was melt-in-your-mouth fresh, and they don’t skimp on portions. The friendly staff were happy to explain the different fish options and help me choose the perfect meal.
Rating: 4.5 (2454 reviews)
Location: 3600 Lower Honoapiilani Rd, Lahaina, HI 96761
Contact: (808) 665-9895
Website: Visit Website
South Maui Fish Company
I recently stopped by this amazing seafood spot in Kihei, and I was blown away! South Maui Fish Company is a charming rustic food cart that serves some of the freshest seafood I’ve tasted on the island.
Their menu focuses on the catch of the day, which means everything is super fresh. I tried their poke bowl, which was packed with flavorful chunks of fish and perfectly seasoned. The fish tacos are another must-try item that had me coming back for more.
What I love most about this place is how simple yet delicious everything is. The chefs really know how to let the quality of the seafood shine through. It’s no wonder this little food cart has gained such a following among locals and tourists alike!
Despite being a food cart, the quality rivals many fancy restaurants I’ve visited. The laid-back atmosphere made my dining experience even more enjoyable, and I found myself chatting with other happy customers while waiting for my order.
Rating: 4.7 (1525 reviews)
Location: 1794 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753
Contact: (808) 419-8980
Website: Visit Website
Paia Fish Market South Side
I recently visited Paia Fish Market’s South Side location in Kihei and was blown away by the fresh seafood. The casual, relaxed atmosphere makes it perfect for a post-beach meal when you’re still sandy and sun-soaked.
Their fish dishes are the real stars here. I tried the mahi-mahi plate which came with perfectly grilled fish alongside rice and coleslaw. You can choose how you want your fish prepared – grilled, blackened, or sautéed.
The fish tacos are another must-try item that I’ve ordered multiple times. They’re generously filled with fresh fish and topped with their house-made salsa. The portions are huge, so come hungry!
I love watching the chefs prepare everything right behind the counter. While it can get busy during peak hours, the line moves quickly, and the food is worth any short wait you might experience.
Rating: 4.6 (3342 reviews)
Location: 1913 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753
Contact: (808) 874-8888
Website: Visit Website
Leilani’s on the Beach
I recently visited Leilani’s on the Beach and was blown away by the incredible seafood. Located right on Kaanapali Beach, this restaurant offers amazing ocean views that make dining here extra special.
The fresh fish is definitely the star of the show. They get their seafood delivered daily, and you can really taste the difference. I tried their catch of the day, prepared in traditional Hawaiian style, and it was perfectly cooked.
What makes Leilani’s stand out is the genuine aloha spirit you feel from the moment you walk in. The staff treated me like family, and I noticed many locals celebrating special occasions here – always a good sign!
The tropical drinks complement the seafood perfectly. I sipped on a fruity cocktail while watching the sunset over the ocean. It’s the kind of place where you can relax and truly feel like you’re experiencing the best of Maui.
Rating: 4.5 (3566 reviews)
Location: 2435 Kaanapali Pkwy, Lahaina, HI 96761
Contact: (808) 661-4495
Website: Visit Website
NICKS FISHMARKET
I recently dined at Nick’s Fishmarket and was blown away by the experience. Located in the beautiful Fairmont Kea Lani in Wailea, this upscale seafood restaurant offers an amazing open-air dining experience with stunning views of the Pacific Ocean.
The menu is incredible, featuring fresh seafood sourced directly from local fishermen. Chef Maka personally selects the catch before sunrise, ensuring only the highest quality makes it to your plate. I tried their opakapaka (Hawaiian pink snapper) which was beautifully prepared with a blend of Mediterranean and Hawaiian flavors.
What makes Nick’s truly special is their commitment to using local ingredients. From Molokai sweet potatoes to Hamakua mushrooms, they showcase Hawaii’s best produce while supporting local farmers. The service matches the food quality – attentive, friendly staff who guide you through the menu with genuine aloha spirit.
The ambiance is magical, especially during sunset. As darkness falls, tiki torches and elegant lighting illuminate the space, with the hotel’s pool becoming a stunning backdrop. For seafood lovers visiting Maui, this place is an absolute must-visit.
Rating: 4.5 (575 reviews)
Location: 4100 Wailea Alanui Dr, Kihei, HI 96753
Contact: (808) 879-7224
Website: Visit Website
Coconuts Fish Cafe – Kamaole Location
I recently visited Coconuts Fish Cafe in Kihei. Their famous fish tacos blew me away! The restaurant has a fun surf shack vibe that perfectly captures the island’s laid-back atmosphere.
The menu focuses on fresh, light dishes inspired by Hawaii’s Asia-Pacific heritage. I loved that they use wild-caught fish in their signature dishes. They also offer plenty of healthy and gluten-free options that don’t sacrifice flavor.
The warm, welcoming staff truly embodies the Aloha spirit, making every guest feel like family. During my visit, Hawaiian music played softly in the background while colorful surf art decorated the walls.
What impressed me most was their commitment to sustainability – they even recycle all their used cooking oil into biofuel! This place is more than just great seafood; it’s a taste of authentic Maui with every bite.
Rating: 4.5 (2130 reviews)
Location: 2463 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753
Contact: (808) 875-4949
Website: Visit Website
Mala Ocean Tavern
I recently visited Mala Ocean Tavern in Lahaina and was blown away by the experience. This intimate beachfront spot offers the perfect combination of stunning ocean views and amazing food. As I sat at my table, I could hear the gentle waves lapping against the shore.
The menu features a wonderful blend of Pacific Rim and Mediterranean cuisine. I tried their fresh seafood, which they source directly from local fishermen. The ahi and mahi-mahi were absolutely delicious and you can really taste the difference when seafood is this fresh!
What makes Mala truly special is its romantic atmosphere. I watched a breathtaking Maui sunset while enjoying my meal, with the sky transitioning through beautiful shades of yellow, pink, and orange. It’s definitely one of the most scenic dining spots I’ve found on the island.
The restaurant has a family-friendly vibe too, making it perfect for various occasions. Whether you’re planning a romantic dinner or a casual family meal, Mala Ocean Tavern delivers both on atmosphere and flavor.
Rating: 4.6 (2378 reviews)
Location: 1307 Front St, Lahaina, HI 96761
Contact: (808) 667-9394
Website: Visit Website
Paia Fish Market Restaurant
I recently visited Paia Fish Market Restaurant on Maui and was blown away by the fresh seafood! This casual spot has a charming nautical theme with indoor picnic tables that create a friendly, communal atmosphere.
The menu is seafood heaven. I tried their signature dish seared with Cajun spice, served on a bed of cabbage. It was absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. You can choose how you want your fish prepared, and it comes with crunchy cole slaw, tartar sauce, and your choice of sides.
What I love about this place is its history. Opened in 1989 when Paia was just a sleepy fishing town, it has maintained its laid-back vibe where people gather to “talk story” over amazing food. The family-style seating encourages you to make new friends while enjoying some of the best seafood on the island.
Don’t miss their fresh Maui corn tortillas with melted cheese and your choice of fish. I found the portions generous and the prices reasonable for the quality you get. This is definitely a must-visit spot for seafood lovers on Maui!
Rating: 4.6 (4752 reviews)
Location: 100 Hana Hwy, Paia, HI 96779
Contact: (808) 579-8030
Website: Visit Website
Freshness Matters
When I’m looking for seafood in Maui, I always pay attention to how fresh the fish is. The best restaurants on the island take pride in serving fish caught daily from local waters.
Locally Sourced Ingredients
I’ve noticed that Mama’s Fish House is famous for its commitment to freshness. They even list the name of the fisherman who caught your meal on the menu! This connection to local fishing creates an authentic Hawaiian dining experience.
Many top seafood spots like The Fish Market Maui focus on serving what was caught that morning. The difference in taste between fresh-caught Hawaiian fish and imported seafood is remarkable.
I love visiting restaurants that work directly with local fishermen. Places like Paia Fish Market offer that “right-off-the-boat” freshness that’s impossible to beat.
Sustainable Fishing Practices
I believe supporting restaurants that practice sustainable fishing is essential for Maui’s marine ecosystem. Many local establishments partner with fishermen who use traditional line-catching methods rather than harmful nets.
Merriman’s is one of my favorites for their commitment to sustainability. They source from fishermen who follow pono (righteous) fishing practices.
When I talk to locals, they often recommend places that respect fishing seasons and avoid endangered species. This ensures we can enjoy Hawaiian seafood for generations to come.
I’ve learned that restaurants serving sustainable seafood often taste better too! Fish caught using sustainable methods tend to be handled with more care from ocean to plate.
Ambiance and Dining Experience
When dining at Maui’s seafood restaurants, the atmosphere enhances your meal just as much as the food. The island’s natural beauty and cultural influences create unforgettable settings for enjoying fresh seafood.
Oceanfront Views
Many of Maui’s top seafood spots offer breathtaking ocean views that create a magical dining experience. At Mala Ocean Tavern, I love watching waves crash against the shore while enjoying my meal. The restaurant sits right on the waterfront in Lahaina, making it perfect for sunset dinners.
Nick’s Fishmarket in Wailea offers an “enchanting Mediterranean setting” with ocean views that complement their upscale seafood dishes. I find the sound of nearby waves adds a peaceful soundtrack to dinner.
Mama’s Fish House features one of my favorite views on the island, with its location on a secluded beach in Paia. The panoramic ocean vistas make it popular for special occasions and romantic dinners.
Island-Inspired Decor
Maui’s seafood restaurants often reflect Hawaii’s rich cultural heritage. Many places use natural materials like bamboo, wood, and stone to create warm, inviting spaces.
Restaurants with the best ambiance often incorporate traditional Hawaiian elements like tiki torches, local artwork, and flower arrangements featuring tropical blooms. These touches create an authentic island feel.
At Mama’s Fish House, the Polynesian-inspired decor with historic photos, fishing artifacts, and handcrafted furniture is adorable. The attention to detail makes dining feel like a cultural experience.
Many restaurants also feature open-air designs that welcome gentle trade winds. This design approach helps me feel connected to Maui’s natural beauty even while dining.
